Accountancy Age blog: Insider with Gavin Hinks Accountancy Age blog: Insider with Gavin Hinks A blog from Accountancy Age

« Wenham Major's troubles | Main | It's the job - piss someone off! »

IAS39: 'Like drunks getting into a car after crashing another..'

Rarely has there been such a scathing attack. Tim Bush, director at Hermes Asset Management, and scurge of regulators, chose today to air forthright views over fair value accounting and, in particular, IAS39, the standard that deals with ‘financial instruments’, or mortgages.

On IAS39 he said: ‘It’s like watching drunks getting in a car after crashing another, and it was the regulators who gave them the car keys.’ That drew a sharp intake of breath from the breakfast gathering at

Moorgate Place

, who found themselves choking on their morning pastries .

Bush’s next move was to describe IAS39 as ‘legitimised market abuse’.

 

Then he turned on the International Accounting Standards Board comparing it to a ‘tractor factory’. ‘It’s a command and control model from the 1970s.’

 

And just as everyone thought they could eat in peace he said: ‘Change the board – they’re yesterday’s men.’

 

Never has the IASB and one of its standard had such a public malling (actually, that may not be true. IASB chairman Sir David Tweedie has been brutalised in the

US

on more than one occasion and appears to thrive on it) by someone in such a public place as

Moorgate Place

’s Great Hall.

In fact Bush’s presentation was not just mud slinging, he went at some substantive issues pretty vigorously too, which, I can say, at least impressed the people sitting immediately around me.

But it is worth bearing in mind IAS39 will change. The IASB is consulting and yesterday hosted a webcast, involving 600 people, to discuss the issue. The top brass at the IASB is well aware that something is wrong and I am told they look forward to seeing Tim Bush’s submission to the consultation.

TrackBack

TrackBack URL for this entry:
http://blogs-1.gos.vnu.net/mt-tb.cgi/84152

Listed below are links to weblogs that reference IAS39: 'Like drunks getting into a car after crashing another..'.

Comments

Post a comment

Useful links: About | Privacy policy | Terms & conditions | Top of the page
© Incisive Media Ltd. 2008
Incisive Media Limited, Haymarket House, 28-29 Haymarket, London SW1Y 4RX, is a company registered in the United Kingdom with company registration number 04038503